Advertisement Trevor Sova was an early fan favorite on the show after he was on the losing end of a love triangle with Chelsea Blackwell and Jimmy Presnell. In the end, Jimmy and Chelsea chose one another, leaving Trevor blindsided and heartbroken — and that led to Trevor getting a ton of love on social media. Natalia, a North Carolina-based bodybuilder who told BI that she and Trevor were in a serious relationship before and throughout filming of the show.